skip past navigation links
pixel

Technologists (P6 die photo) about archives notes tidbits (RSS) music vidconf.net

Technologists.com
pixel
home > tidbits > tidbit070119 > windows
Distance Multimedia: 4 score & more

pixel
permanent reference link
pixel
pixel January 19, 2007 -- Until the 1980s, windowing wasn't even a part of commercial operating systems and didn't become prominent until 1984. Though the Mac OS windowing model has evolved considerably since the OS 7 model on my first Performa, it has never really felt comfortable with multiple applications. Today on OS X I seem to work hard to switch between windows the way I am used to doing effortlessly in Microsoft Windows. The nominal benefit of having the windows of an application be so naturally independent of each other often makes me hide/reveal windows twice at a time, once for the application and once for the OS. Apple may have taken a "if you can't fix it, feature it" attitude to the problem when they developed and promoted Exposé.
pixel
pixel The problem is exacerbated by the "low" resolution (1024x768) of my iBook. Apple's Exposé screen shots portray a wide monitor, probably with more than 768 vertical pixels. With the same 10x7 resolution on the Latitude I do not have similar problems positioning, sizing and switching between windows. Nor do I have similar problems in X Windows on Linux or Unix. Does anyone else agree?
pixel
pixel However, just as OS X seems to suffer from windowing decisions made two decades ago, X Windows seems obsolete in light of 20 years of experience. To oversimplify, OS X suffers from inflexibility while X Windows suffers from too much flexibility. An obvious aspect is the separation of the window manager from the windowing infrastructure, leading to long history of contending window managers. Today's competitors include GNOME, KDE, and Enlightenment. X has a long history of detractors and competitors, but seems firmly entrenched in all of the Unix-derivative platforms besides OS X. Also, Microsoft gradually abandoning keyboard methods for managing windows has aggravated me. Apparently, Vista makes this worse: Remember CUA Compliance? Microsoft Doesn't.
pixel
pixel


Back to Top

Copyright © 1995-2016 Charles H. Sauer. All rights reserved.

pixel